Fixel Prototype

Created by Wing H To, UCSB HEX Group, CMS: 2 April 2013
Last Updated On: 26 April 2013



Physics Motivations:
  • Utilize Radially Pixelated Fiber for fast track recontruction for CMS Detector.
  • Ability to read out and reconstruct tracks at the L1 trigger level. (~25 ns)
  • Converage of CMS detector in |eta| < 2.1.
  • Enough momentum resolution to trigger off low momentum charged particles.

Project Goals:
  • Build a prototype of Fixel detector with ~ 16 channels with fast read out electronics.
  • Build a scintillation triggering system to confirm events with cosmic muons.
Setup up for FTB with a single channel

Building the Scintillators for Triggering:
  • Scintillators are BC-408 from Saint Gobains.Datasheet
BC-408
  • Two 10x10 cm2 squares of the scintillators were cut out to build a two layer trigger.
  • The BC408 was first cut using a band saw (rough cut), then cut using a fly cutter on a mill (smooth cut). The fly cutter was able to make a smooth surface of ~ 100 um in deviations.
BC-408
  • The "smooth" edge were first sanded down using a fine sandpaper (220 Grit). Then polished using a heavy #3 polish from Novus, then a fine #2 polish from Novus and buffed using #1 Plastic clean and shine from Novus.
BC-408

Coupling WLS fibers onto the BC408:
Requirements:
  • Be able to transmit 425 nm light from the scintillator to SiPM which has good efficiency at 425 but the highest is at 525. WLS fiber would be ideal but not necessary.
  • Each Scintillator will have 2 cables on it with both ends of the cable connected to SiPM. So 1 Slab = 4 output.
  • Perimeter per loop is ~ 40 cm (depends on rounding of edges). Each Slab = 2 fibers. We have 2 slabs.... Length required = 40*4*NLoops.   • Since the fibers are so thin a minimum of 4 loops should be taken.... This will require at least 6.5 meters of fibers.
Fiber candidates:
200 um UV VIS bare fiber from whitebearphotonics.com
This fiber has a minimum bending radius of 4 cm at 200 um thickness and transmission between 200 to 800 nm. Cost $16/meter. It will probably comes in a polymer cladding which can be burnt off on part of the fiber which needs to be in contact with the scintillator.
Order Page
Bending Radius
Asked Debbie to order 10 meters of these fibers since they're the cheapest and actually response to their emails.

200 um UV VIS bare fiber from AccuGlassProducts.com
Need to confirm bend radius for 200 um fibers.
Accu Glass Rep noted that the Polyimide Buff can be burnt off with a small flame.
Cost $40 / meter.
Order Page

500 um WLS fibers from Kuraray.
Comes in square cross section for better stacking and coupling to slab.
Y-8 Version seems to accept 450 nm light and emits 511 nm light.(blue to green)
Hard to contact.. Emailed rep
Info Page
WLS Page

250 um WLS fiber from Saint Gobain
Same story as above. Contacted by email..
WLS Page

Read out signals from Scintillation slabs
Plan to have SiPM detectors at both ends of each fiber.
AdvanSiD SiPM.
For now, we use Hamamatsu SiPM MPPC to test the output.
Hamamatsu SiPM.
A Hamamatsu MPPC had a broken Pot (10kOhm). It was replaced with another Surface Mounted Pots of 20kOhm.
Need a way to couple the ends of the fiber into the MPPC windows.
Hamamatsu MPPC
Picture above shows the 20kOhm Pot replaced on the bottom right of the picture.
The Pot seems to tune the voltage output on the analog output. The pot was adjusted until the output was at 0 mV for no dark current as shown below.
Dark currents

The search for optically clear epoxy.
Masterbond seems to have a good epoxy for our purpose.
Unfortunately it seems to come in 1/2 pint sizes...
Masterbond
Datasheet
Transmission spectrum update from Masterbond
EP30 Transmission
EP30 Datasheet

Buffer removal from Fiber
Fibers will come in polyimide buffer (10 um) and cladding material (10 um).
These have to be remove from the part of the fiber which couples to the scintillation slab.
Accu-glass claimed that they be burnt off.
I tried this with 100 um fiber I borrowed from Marian.
Burning the fiber with a lighter leaves a black coating behind(too hot?).
Cleaning this with some soapy water actually broke the fibers in multiple places.
The fiber became very bittle after the buffer has been burned off.
Looks like there are specific tools to remove buffer and cladding from fibers
Fiber stripper

Fixel Trigger Board (FTB) Test
Stuffed FTB with PreAmp, Amp and Integrator components only for testing.
FTB_Stuffed_PA_Amp_Int
No signal test. The PreAmpOut1 has a ringing ~ 10 mV. This creates a large offset at the AmpOut2
FTB_YellowPAOut2_BlueAOut2_NoSignal_49ResistorOnAmpIn2
FTB_YellowPAOut2_BlueAOut2_NoSignal_49ResistorOnAmpIn2
Replaced R12 on Amp1. Reduced Amp1 gain from 40 to 2.
FTB_YellowPAOut1_BlueAOut1_NoSignal_1kResistorOnAmpIn1
FTB_YellowPAOut1_BlueAOut1_NoSignal_1kResistorOnAmpIn1
MPPC Output with 70.7V Bias on U100s Serial Number 561 and 562 on 2mm by 5cm long scintilating crystals with Sr70 source.
MPPC U100s output with the Sr70 is approximately 100 mV with a 33k Ohm resistor. Current generated should be about ~ 3 uA.
Blue is readout from 561 MPPC.
Yellow is readout from 562 MPPC.
MPPC_U100_561And562On2mm5cmCrystal_Sr70_70000
Hooking the MPPC output into the FTB's transimpedance amplifier gave about 350 mV output at the PreAmp. The TransAmp resistance is 2k which shows that the amplified current is about 175 uA. The final amplifer should give 2x that on channel 1 which correct for the Amp's configuration (2k / 1k Ohm OpAmp).
Blue is readout from 561 MPPC.
Yellow is read out from PreAmp1 using signal from 562 MPPC.
Purple is readout from Amp1.
MPPC_U100_561And562On2mm5cmCrystal_Sr70_ThroughAmplifers
We kept Channel 2 with the original configuration with a 40x Amplifier (2k / 50 Ohm OpAmp). 300 mV from here should give 12V output. Of course this saturates the Amplifier, but it doesn't seem saturate as fast as expected on the turn on curve. Saturation sould occur at 100 mV on the yellow curve. Which is ~ 1.5 ns after trig, but it doesn't seem to occur until 10 ns after trigger. The fall gives a better agreement between PreAmp*40 = AmpOut.
Blue is readout from 561 MPPC.
Yellow is read out from PreAmp2 using signal from 562 MPPC.
Purple is readout from Amp2.
MPPC_U100_561And562On2mm5cmCrystal_Sr70_ThroughAmplifers

With the appropriate choice of R+, the effects of Input Bias Current can be minimized with the resistor on the non-inverting terminal of the op amp.
Choice of R+
Blue is readout from 561 MPPC.
Yellow is read out from PreAmp2 using signal from 562 MPPC.
Purple is readout from Int2.
FTB_Sr90_SiPMTrig_PAmp2_Int2000
Schematics and Components on FTB.
FTB_PreAmp.pdf
FTB-Amp.pdf
FTB-INT.pdf

Output from Chn 3 with lowered Amplifier (x4).
400 mV (current through 33k Ohm resistor) output is PA to ~ 1 V. Then the Amp increased the output to ~ 4V.
Yellow Signal.
Blue PAOut3
Purplse AmpOut3
Channel 3 on the left, Channel 4 on the right.
FTB_Ch3_SiPMTrig_PAout3_AmpOut3 FTB_Ch4_SiPMTrig_PAout4_AmpOut4
Yellow Signal.
Blue IntOut3
Purplse SHOut3
The integrator's output peaks about 1 V also. While the Sample and Hold in Sampling mode has an output peaking about 200 mV. There's also a delay between the Signal and the S&H signal. FTB_Ch3_SiPMTrig_IntOut3_SHOut3 FTB_Ch4_SiPMTrig_IntOut4_SHOut4

Yellow Signal.
Blue AmpOut3(4)
Purplse DiscOut3(4)
FTB_Trig_AmpOut3_Disc3 FTB_Trig_AmpOut4_Disc4
Yellow Signal.
Blue Digital Out 4
When the probe is applied to the Digital output there's a feedback which affects the signal coming out of the otherside of the SIPM.
FTB_SiPM_Trig_DOut4

Yellow Signal.
Blue TrigOut
This is done by putting a fake signal into the other three channels.
Channel 2 is broken so a 5 V bias is place into the discriminator output directly
Channel 3 and 4 is supplied with a 5 V / 1k current to drive the Transimpedence amplifier.
FTB_FinalOutput002
Picture of FTB with breadboard. Top SiPM is routed to trigger for the scope, the bottom SiPM output is supplied to channel 2 of the preamplifier input. Channel two still has a 40X amplifier so it's actually better to move this Channel 3 or 4 in actual test.
FTB_BreadBoard
Picture of FTB with wires attached for readout and fake signals.
FTB_WithWires
Instructions to get TrigOutput from FTB using a single SiPM signal.
Connect Ribbon with Pin 1 on the bottom left with respect to the orientation in photo.
Red Circle: Apply 5V Bias.
Blue Circle: Apply 5V / 1k current (5 mA).
Black Circle: SiPM Signal.
Yellow Circle: TrigOutput.
FTB_Alone


June 19th 2013 Update
FTB2 for Noah's Sample and Hold Testing.
Final FTB2 setup with 2 SiPM readout of a 2x2mm^2 and 2 Fake Constant 5V Signal. Trigger Pulse on 4 channels coincidences Green. Amplified output from the two SiPMs in Yellow and Magenta. FTB2_HamSiPM_TrigOut_Sig1_Sig2_SourceOn_70V
Some Useful Alteration to FTB
Put SMD POT away from each other, any plastic components, any "Tall" components.
Small Through-Hole probes for PreAmp, Amp, Bias Voltage, Threshold Voltage, Integrator, (maybe also) discriminator.
Modify Integrator and Amplifier Resistance so Resistance to Ground on the Non-inverting input = Resistance of Inverting Input parallel to feedback resistor to remove bias current voltage.
We still haven't figure out how to ge the switch to work
Make the board size fit into one of these black boxes we have in the lab.

June 20th 2013 Update
I mounted the U50 (previously bendy) SiPMs onto the 5mm crystal we were using to test the effect of the use of glue and grease and the see why we do not get decent signal from the source or cosmic from the AdvSiD SiPMs.
First test, a Pair of Hamamatsu U50s serial number 516 and 517 with gain of 7.5e5 per photoelectron. Mounted onto the 5x5x50 mm^3 scintilation crystals with teflon and black type wrapping.
Scope traces with the Sr90 Source on the scintillator. The signal looks very clean without any coupling grease. The Amplified output is on the order of 0.5V per photon electron. The preamp output gives about 200 mV = 4V/200 as expected. Trigger is at about 2-5 Hz.
Yellow AmpOutRight
Blue AmpOutLeft
Magenta PreAmpRight
Green FTB2 Trigger
FTB2_Sr90_U50SiPMs_On5mmCrystal_Sr90
Scope traces without any Source on the scintillator. This took about 1 minutes of waiting for the trigger. Rate is ~ 0.03 Hz. This is most likley a cosmic. The signal also looks very clean.
Yellow AmpOutRight
Blue AmpOutLeft
Magenta PreAmpRight
Green FTB2 Trigger
FTB2_Sr90_U50SiPMs_On5mmCrystal_NoSrc

July 9th 2013 Update
I wrapped 3 plastic optical fibers onto the scintillating puck. Each side of the fiber goes to a different SiPM. Three fibers are coupled into each SiPM.
The scintillator doesn't seem to give off light in conincidence. When I trigger off channel 1, channel 2 is basically flat and vice versa. The amount of light that I can trigger on is failry high in the dark box. This is approximately 3-4 times higher than what I was able to trigger on with 1 fiber per SiPM. We about 1.5V trigger at about 10 Hz on Channel 2 and Channel 1 gives about 2.2V Amplified Output at about 10 Hz.
ScinSlab003001
Yellow Output from Channel 1 Triggering on Channel 2.
ScinSlab003002
Yellow Output from Channel 1 Triggering on Channel 2.
ScinSlab003003
Yellow Output from Channel 2 Triggering on Channel 1.
ScinSlab003004
Yellow Output from Channel 2 Triggering on Channel 1.

July 10th 2013 Update
Due to the failure to get coincidences on the Scintillation Puck. We wanted to try two different tests.
A: Make sure that the scintillator does scintillate.
To do this we cut out a 1x1x5 cm^3 rod out of the scintillator slab and mounted two SiPM end to end as we do with the precut scintillator.
Noah and I used a band saw and fly cutter to make one of these rod in the machine shop.
Noah sanded and polished up the rough sides of the scintillator as usual.
I wrapped it up in Teflon + black tape and attached two SiPM end to end to it.
These are the initial signal we see out of the Amplifier output of the SiPM on FTB2.
The Trigger is on the order of about 10 Hz with the Beta source next to the crystal and went down to about 0.05 Hz with just cosmics.
The signal looks very clean and synchronized between the two sides.
ScinSlab_Jul10001
ScinSlab_Jul10002
ScinSlab_Jul10003
With Beta Source.
ScinSlab_Jul10_NoSrc000
ScinSlab_Jul10_NoSrc001
Cosmics only.

B: Use the 0.5x0.5x5 cm^3 Scintillator as the trigger and place the puck underneath to see if the signals we're getting are from cosmics.
I made an additional voltage divider on the bread board to supply the U50 with 70.6V and U100s with 69.6V.
When I tried to test this on FTB2, channel PA2B does not respond.
Removing all the signal sources, there's a bias of 50mV on PA2B output and -1V on A2B output.
This behavior shouldn't exist and does not exist on the other three channels.
Amp2 OpAmp also heats up as the testing goes on.
There were some modification done to the board for Noah's testing purpose.
I have started assembling FTB4 with only the analog component for Scintillator testing purpose only.


July 11th 2013 Update
Characterization of SiPMs on their respective scintillators using FTB2
U100 pair on 1x1x5cm^3 scintillator rod.
Hamamatsu SiPM U100 Serial: 561
Hamamatsu SiPM U100 Serial: 562
We set the trigger threshold to various voltages and check for coincidence on both sides of the scintillator

Bias Voltage at 69.6V on both SiPM. Background are non-coincidence counts with the beta source on the scintillator

Triggering on 561 @ 0.50V - 15 Background / 20 Events
Triggering on 561 @ 0.75V - 4 Background / 20 Events
Triggering on 561 @ 1.00V - 4 Background / 20 Events
Triggering on 561 @ 1.25V - 2 Background / 20 Events

Triggering on 562 @ 0.50V - 1 Background / 20 Events
Triggering on 562 @ 0.75V - 1 Background / 20 Events
Triggering on 562 @ 1.00V - 0 Background / 20 Events

Recommended Threshold for 561 @ 1.3V
Recommended Threshold for 562 @ 0.75V
Using these threhold voltage, we trigger on coindence on both SiPM and measured the rate using the beta source and cosmics.
Beta Source: ~ 25 Hz
Cosmic: 3 coincidence / 30 seconds. 0.1 Hz.



U50 pair on 0.5x0.5x5cm^3 scintillator fiber.
Hamamatsu SiPM U50 Serial: 916
Hamamatsu SiPM U50 Serial: 917
We set the trigger threshold to various voltages and check for coincidence on both sides of the scintillator

Bias Voltage at 70.6V on both SiPM. Background are non-coincidence counts with the beta source on the scintillator

Triggering on 916 @ 0.50V - 20 Background / 20 Events
Triggering on 916 @ 0.75V - 7 Background / 20 Events
Triggering on 916 @ 1.00V - 6 Background / 20 Events
Triggering on 916 @ 1.25V - 1 Background / 20 Events

Triggering on 917 @ 0.50V - 19 Background / 20 Events
Triggering on 917 @ 0.75V - 115Background / 20 Events
Triggering on 917 @ 1.00V - 3 Background / 20 Events
Triggering on 917 @ 1.25V - 3 Background / 20 Events
Triggering on 917 @ 1.40V - 0 Background / 20 Events

Recommended Threshold for 916 @ 1.3V
Recommended Threshold for 917 @ 1.3V

Using these threhold voltage, we trigger on coindence on both SiPM and measured the rate using the beta source and cosmics.
Beta Source: ~ 100 Hz
Cosmic: 3 coincidence / 60 seconds. 0.05 Hz.

Task B for today is also testing the large scintillator slab to see why we're not getting coincidence on the puck / square scintillators.
A U100 Serial Number 563 was attached to the square scintillator on side.
The 1x1x5 Rod with two U100 are placed into the daughter card slots on FTB4.
FTB4 is then place on top of the Square Scintillator.
The Beta source is placed on top of the rod scintillator.
Yellow and Blue are the Amplified read out from the Rod.
Magenta is the Amplified read out from the Square.
Triggering is done on the yellow channel on the rod.
ScinSlab_Jul11_Beta000
ScinSlab_Jul11_Beta001
We see conincidence 95% of the time between all three channels.

The beta ray source was removed to see what happens with cosmics.
ScinSlab_Jul11_Cosmic000
ScinSlab_Jul11_Cosmic001
With cosmics, the rate went down to about 0.1 Hz as usual.
The AmpOut from the square went off the scale with 50mV/Div.
The MIP on a thicker scintillator probably gave out more light.
ScinSlab_Jul11_Cosmic004
Square Scin. with 100 mV/Div.
ScinSlab_Jul11_Cosmic006
Square Scin. with 500 mV/Div.
ScinSlab_Jul11_Cosmic007
ScinSlab_Jul11_Cosmic008
We can see that we do get conindences between all 3 channels on cosmics, but the amount of light collected by the SiPM on the square slab varies greatly. This probably caused by the amount of light loss within the crystal. This square slab was wrapped with 2 layers of Teflon + 1 layer of Aluminum foil. There might be a lot of losses due to the scratches on the sides of the scintillator since we won't have an air tight contact between the Teflon and Scintillator on most of the surface..